The North Rhine-Westphalia state government wants to scale back the extraction of sand and gravel and place greater emphasis on recycling. The sand and gravel industry firmly rejects this and warns of job losses, rising construction costs and a threat to supplies for housing, roads and bridges. Sascha Kruchen of the Initiative Zukunft Niederrhein says that phasing out sand and gravel extraction means phasing out security of supply.
Business representatives point to a new legal opinion by Walter Frenz of RWTH Aachen University, presented on 20 November, which questions the data on the raw materials available in the region. Environment Minister Oliver Krischer disagrees: the more building materials are reused, the less land is lost to new quarrying. Economics Minister Mona Neubaur makes a similar argument.
The debate has been given added urgency by the Higher Administrative Court in Münster, which had declared the previous planning for the Ruhr regional plan invalid.
Key points:
- The state government wants to scale back raw material extraction and place greater emphasis on recycling.
- The sand and gravel industry, however, warns of job losses and rising construction costs.
- Sascha Kruchen of the Initiative Zukunft Niederrhein says: "Phasing out sand and gravel extraction means phasing out security of supply."
Source: WDR (German)
